Top 10 Most Expensive Premier League Signings Ever – November 2025

      The Premier League has spent more than £18 billion on transfers since 1992 — and in 2025, the numbers have officially lost all meaning. €100 million is no longer elite; it’s entry-level. As of November 29, 2025, here is the definitive, fully updated ranking of the 10 most expensive signings in Premier League history (including all add-ons), with current player values, performances, and the final verdict on whether the fee was genius, robbery, or pure disaster. From Moisés Caicedo’s British record to Chelsea’s billion-pound spree and the Saudi exodus, these are the deals that redefined the world’s richest league.

#10 – Antony – Ajax → Manchester United (€95m + €5m add-ons, August 2022)

Current value: €28m 12 goals + 5 assists in 95 appearances. The step-overs are still there, the end product isn’t. Loaned to Fenerbahçe in 2025 after falling out with the manager. One of the worst value transfers in Premier League history — United are still trying to offload him.

#9 – Mykhailo Mudryk – Shakhtar Donetsk → Chelsea (€70m + €30m add-ons, January 2023)

Current value: €35m 7 goals + 7 assists in 68 games. Flashes of brilliance (that solo goal vs Arsenal), but inconsistency and off-field issues have Chelsea fans tearing their hair out. Still only 24 — verdict: too early, but leaning toward flop.

#8 – Wesley Fofana – Leicester City → Chelsea (€80m + €10m add-ons, August 2022)

Current value: €40m Injuries have been cruel — only 52 appearances in three years. When fit, he’s world-class (3.1 clearances per game, 92% pass accuracy). Verdict: unlucky disaster — Chelsea paid for potential that injuries stole.

#7 – Romelu Lukaku – Inter Milan → Chelsea (€113m, August 2021)

Current value: €35m (Napoli) 8 goals in 36 games. The most expensive flop in Premier League history — sold back to Italy for €30m + add-ons after one season. Chelsea lost over £80m. Verdict: absolute catastrophe.

#6 – Jadon Sancho – Borussia Dortmund → Manchester United (€85m, July 2021)

Current value: €30m Exiled after public fallout with Ten Hag, loaned back to Dortmund, now at Chelsea. The biggest “what could have been” story in Premier League history. Verdict: massive disappointment.

#5 – Jack Grealish – Aston Villa → Manchester City (£117.5m, August 2021)

Current value: €70m 2 Premier Leagues, 1 Champions League, 1 FA Cup. Never became the main man, but his flair in big games (2023 UCL final assist, 2024 FA Cup semi-final winner) has been vital. Pep calls him “irreplaceable in the dressing room.” Verdict: expensive, but part of a winning machine.

#4 – Enzo Fernández – Benfica → Chelsea (€121m, January 2023)

Current value: €95m World Cup winner at 21, now Chelsea captain at 24. 8 assists this season, 92% pass accuracy, 2.8 tackles per game. Finally showing why Chelsea broke the British record. Verdict: starting to look like a bargain.

#3 – Declan Rice – West Ham → Arsenal (€116.6m, July 2023)

Current value: €120m England’s best midfielder, Arsenal’s leader. 3.2 tackles + 2.1 interceptions per 90, 8 assists this season. Title-challenging form. £105m + £11.6m add-ons now looks like a steal. Verdict: the best value £100m+ signing ever.

#2 – Josko Gvardiol – RB Leipzig → Manchester City (€90m, July 2023)

Current value: €95m Champions League winner, 5 assists this season from left-back, 88% pass accuracy. Pep’s perfect modern defender — comfortable on the ball, ruthless in the tackle, and a weapon going forward. Verdict: bargain at €90m.

#1 – Moisés Caicedo – Brighton → Chelsea (€116m + €16m add-ons, August 2023)

Current value: €110m The most expensive Premier League signing ever. 3.8 tackles + 2.8 interceptions per 90, Chelsea unbeaten when he starts. The Ecuadorian is proving the fee was worth it — the new British record holder and justifying every penny. Verdict: the deal that broke the market — and delivered.

Conclusion

The Premier League transfer market is officially broken — £100m+ is the new normal. Rice and Caicedo are proving their worth, but Lukaku, Antony, and Sancho will haunt their clubs forever. Which signing was the best value? The biggest robbery? Drop your take in the comments — I reply to every one!

Disclaimer: Fees include add-ons. Values from Transfermarkt, November 2025. See our Privacy Policy for details.